Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar

4.6 ( 307 reviews )
Checking... 11:00 AM - 9:30 PM See Hours
$10–20
115 Division St, Kelleys Island, OH 43438, United States
+1 419-746-2518
Nestled in the heart of Kelleys Island, Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar has quickly become a local favorite, earning rave reviews for its outstanding food and vibrant atmosphere. Patrons like Tony E highlight their "ABSOLUTE best wings EVER," describing them as a must-try alongside their delectable pizzas. The reviews reflect an overwhelming love for the restaurant's unique offerings, including their beloved Homer sub, a dish touted by KJ Hanna as a generous feast perfect for sharing with friends or family. For pizza enthusiasts, Caddy Shack excels with rave descriptions of their thin, crispy crust and innovative toppings—especially the white pizza adorned with spinach, tomatoes, and pine nuts, praised as "the best in Ohio" by long-time summer visitors. The emphasis on fresh ingredients and flavorful combinations resonates through every review, painting a picture of culinary dedication. Additionally, the outdoor seating, complemented by a lively ambiance featuring live music, enhances the dining experience, making it a perfect getaway spot. With an enticing beer selection to match its impressive menu, Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar seamlessly combines good eats with a laid-back vibe, promising an unforgettable experience that keeps guests coming back for more.

Amenities and More

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • No delivery
  • Highlights
    • Has bar games
    • Has fast service
    • Has great beer selection
    • Serves great cocktails
    • Has live music
    • Has live performances
    • Good for watching sport
  • Popular for
    • Good for solo dining
  • Offerings
    • Serves alcohol
    • Serves beer
    • Serves cocktails
    • Has dancing
    • Serves food
    • Serves food at bar
    • Serves happy-hour food
    • Serves spirits
    • Serves wine
  • Dining options
    • Has seating
  • Amenities
    • Has toilet
  • Atmosphere
    • Casual
    • Cosy
    • Trendy
  • Crowd
    • Good for groups
    • Popular with tourists
  • Planning
    • Doesn't accept reservations
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards
  • Parking
    • Free of charge street parking
    • Free parking lot
  • Pets
    • Dogs allowed

Reviews For Caddy Shack Restaurant and Bar

Tony E
Jun 1,2025
The ABSOLUTE best wings EVER! Never had wings like this, and WOW, they were delicious! You definitely can't go wrong with the pizza as well. Great sauce, and the cheese is phenomenal! Keep up the great work Brett and staff! Awesome selection of beer too!
KJ Hanna
May 31,2025
Me and my soulmate had a sub called the Homer and it was amazing!!! Prepare yourself to eat a whole bunch if you order that. For 20 at least 4 people can feast that’s why this item is the food deal of the island!!!
Aerial Artistry
Mar 30,2025
Yummy yummy yum yum I love the pizza here you have to get some if you're hungry bring the whole family over here and get a pizza
Toni Kline
Mar 21,2025
We have been on KI every summer since 1972. The Caddy Shack has the absolute BEST pizza. Ever!!!! We especially love the white pizza with spinach, tomatoes and PINE NUTS!!! And the mushroom pizza, the pepperoni pizza are superb.. Most amazing to me is the Crust.. So delicious..i don't know how it is made and what special ingredients but by far the best I have found in Ohio.. Thank youbCaddy Shack cooks and waiters.....
Chris T
Mar 9,2025
Fantastic pizza, great beer selection! Outdoor seating and live music!
Josh Notley
Feb 27,2025
Awesome place with Great Pizza and Subs along with a draft list that is out of this world! 47 Taps! They do the absolute best Grilled Wings but only on certain days!
Josiah Kimble
Feb 16,2025
Best pizza I have ever had in my life!!!
Ali Bader
Feb 6,2025
Tends to be pretty busy but you can get a LOT of food here. We got the Homer (sandwich) which is MASSIVE and the Kamehameha pizza. Took about 30 ish minutes to arrive. The live music is fun. They play games occasionally with the audience (i.e. Phil Collins vs Genesis etc) Also a decent place to watch the fireworks during Island Fest etc

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

The Thirsty Sportsman
(228 review)
The Thirsty Sportsman
  • 205 N Armstrong St, Crothersville, IN 47229, United States
Bar
+1 812-793-3326
Bella Colibri
(199 review)
Bella Colibri
  • 812 12th St, Golden, CO 80401, United States
Italian restaurant
+1 720-289-4859
Parkade Bar & Grill
(268 review)
Parkade Bar & Grill
  • 207 W Kennewick Ave, Kennewick, WA 99336, United States
Bar
+1 509-586-6006
Sierra's Brick Oven Pizza
(427 review)
Sierra's Brick Oven Pizza
  • 370 King St, Franklin, MA 02038, United States
Pizza restaurant
+1 508-530-0868
Olives Et Al in The Potting Shed
(244 review)
Olives Et Al in The Potting Shed
  • Poundbury Farm Way, Poundbury, Dorchester DT1 3RT, United Kingdom
Restaurant
+44 1305 216788
Rolesville Diner
(292 review)
Rolesville Diner
  • 411 S Main St, Rolesville, NC 27571, United States
Breakfast restaurant
+1 919-554-9331
Eastcut Sandwich Bar (Durham)
(768 review)
Eastcut Sandwich Bar (Durham)
  • 3211 Old Chapel Hill Rd, Durham, NC 27707, United States
Restaurant
+1 984-439-1852
Tupelo River Coffee
(131 review)
Tupelo River Coffee
  • 522 W Main St, Tupelo, MS 38804, United States
Coffee shop
+1 662-346-8800
Terrasse Pizza
(377 review)
Terrasse Pizza
  • 1100 Mnt Masson, Mascouche, QC J7K 2K7, Canada
Pizza restaurant
+1 450-474-8474
Pepper's Mexican Grill and Cantina
(2891 review)
Pepper's Mexican Grill and Cantina
  • 794 S Atlantic Ave, Ormond Beach, FL 32176, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 386-673-7668